If You Think TDD Means Automated Tests, You’re Missing the Point

Jul 3, 2025 | Technical Excellence, Testing & QA, Developers

This article is part 1 of 1 in the series Beyond Testing – The TDD Series

Let’s get one thing out of the way:

Test-Driven Development (TDD) is not about writing automated tests.

If that sentence rattles you a bit—good. Because too many teams think they’re “doing TDD” when all they’re doing is sprinkling some tests over their code like powdered sugar on a burnt waffle. Looks sweet. Tastes like regret.

I Was You Once

In 2003, I walked past the “Software Testing” department at my university and chuckled. What a waste of time, I thought. After all, in software, everything is deterministic. I write the code, I know what it does. Why would I need a whole department for that?

A year later, I was neck-deep in Extreme Programming, pair programming with professionals, building a real product for a real business. We used JUnit. We did ping-pong TDD. And I got humbled—fast.

I discovered the Red-Green-Refactor cycle. Write a failing test (red). Make it pass (green). Clean up the code (refactor). Repeat.

And I discovered something deeper:

TDD wasn’t slowing me down. It was setting me free.

Why “Automated Tests” ≠ TDD

Here’s the dangerous myth:

“As long as we have automated tests, we’re doing TDD. Right?”

No. Absolutely not. Having tests is like having brakes in your car. TDD is learning how to drive.

Teams that misunderstand this end up abusing mocks, writing brittle test suites that require more maintenance than the production code, and testing implementation details instead of behavior. It’s the software equivalent of teaching your dog to sit by surgically adjusting its knees.

The result? Disillusionment. Frustration. “TDD doesn’t work.”

But here’s the twist:

TDD does work. Just not when it’s done wrong.

So What Is TDD Then?

TDD is not a testing strategy. It’s a development discipline.

It forces you to understand the problem before jumping into the solution.
It shapes your design to be modular, clear, and testable.
It creates a feedback loop so tight that bugs rarely survive.
It transforms your test suite into living documentation—up to date, executable, and written in code, not dusty wikis.

And most of all?

TDD changes how it feels to be a developer.

What It Feels Like to Work in a TDD Team

You don’t lie awake at night wondering if your last refactoring broke something.
You don’t dig through 3,000 lines of spaghetti to figure out where the side effect came from.
You come in in the morning, run the tests, and they tell you exactly what to do next.
No stress. No guesswork.
Just rhythm.

We use Hemingway’s cliffhanger technique: before going home, write a failing test for the next thing. When you come back, boom—you’re in the zone. Flow state in 60 seconds.

The Unexpected Wins

TDD isn’t just about quality. It’s about sustainable pace.

You leave work on time. You sleep better.
You focus on the business problem, not on holding the entire codebase in your head.
You communicate better with your product manager because tests force clarity on what the system should do, not how it might do it.

And when someone new joins the team?

They don’t need a two-week onboarding.
They read the tests. They get it.
They copy-paste the test examples to learn how the system works.

That’s not just productivity.
That’s professionalism.

Why Most Teams Don’t Get There

Because they never got past the powdered sugar phase.
Because someone told them “testing slows you down.”
Because they were pressured to deliver more features instead of better code.
Because they never had someone to show them what TDD really feels like when it’s done right.

Maybe it’s time that changed.


Coming Next in This Series:

Inside the Red-Green-Refactor Cycle: A Ritual for Flow, Feedback, and Fearlessness

  • If You Think TDD Means Automated Tests, You’re Missing the Point

Liked this? Get more for FREE

Subscribe to The Agile Compass and become an even better agile practitioner.
You'll receive valuable in-depth articles on agile topics via email.
Join me in making this world a more agile place ?

    We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.